Reservation
(310) 832-7544
Visit Us
806 S Gaffey St San Pedro, CA 90731 United States
Hello dear
Welcome To Bonello’s New York Pizza
At Bonello’s New York Pizza, we embrace a rich tradition of delivering authentic New York-style pizza to the heart of San Pedro, California. Our story is rooted in a commitment to quality and consistency, with fresh ingredients and expertly crafted pies that keep loyal patrons returning for more. Customers rave about our large pepperoni and black olive pizzas, all while enjoying a vibrant atmosphere complemented by friendly service. Whether you're grabbing a slice during lunch or savoring dinner with family, Bonello’s offers a casual experience with many vegetarian options, outdoor seating, and convenient delivery options, making every visit a delightful affair.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Meatball
Cheese
Antipasto Salad
House Salad
Tuna
Sicilian Style
Bonellos Special
Cheese
$27.00Eggplant Dish
About
Bonello’s New York Pizza
Welcome to Bonello’s New York Pizza, a beloved gem in San Pedro, CA that brings the authentic taste of New York right to your plate. Nestled at 806 S Gaffey St, Bonello’s is not just a pizza joint; it's a culinary experience that ensures each bite tells a story of tradition and quality.
This pizza haven offers an array of utilities that cater to everyone’s needs, from convenient delivery and takeout options, to a comfortable dining atmosphere that includes outdoor seating and options for large groups. Whether you're there for a family lunch, a dinner outing with friends, or a quick slice to fuel your day, Bonello’s is well-equipped to accommodate with wheelchair accessibility and gender-neutral restrooms.
What truly sets Bonello’s apart is its dedication to quality. Diners rave about their pizza, describing it as the best on the West Coast. From the moment you take your first bite, you’re met with a delightful balance of flavors and perfectly baked crust that is hallmark to New York style. As one customer, Christian A., puts it, “the pizza is always fresh, and the service is always great.”
- Vegetarian Options: With ample vegetarian choices, there’s something for everyone here.
- Specials: Don’t forget about the happy hour specials that make every visit even sweeter!
- Payments: They accept various payment methods, including credit cards, Android Pay, Apple Pay, and even cryptocurrency.
- Atmosphere: The casual setting features moderate noise levels, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.
As you savor the robust flavors of their large pepperoni and black olive pizza, you’ll understand why regulars like Tawny B. suggest ordering ahead, as this place tends to get quite busy. Plus, the friendly banter amongst the staff adds a personal touch to your meal, making every visit feel like coming home.
Bonello’s isn't just a meal; it's a culinary tradition that keeps patrons coming back time and again, even from afar. So whether you're a local looking for your new favorite spot or a visitor eager to experience classic New York pizza, Bonello’s New York Pizza guarantees a slice of happiness topped with passion.
For more information, feel free to call them at (310) 832-7544. Don’t miss out on this pizza paradise!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I've had the Bonello's up in Torrance (honestly have no idea if they're related!) But finally had a chance to try the Pedro one. I would've preferred a medium size but they only had small and large. Got a large pepperoni and black olive pizza and this is a delicious and solid NY style pizza. They do get pretty busy so order before you're hungry!! Definitely will be coming back here. Extra points for the funny banter my husband overheard from the staff! ”
“ The absolute best pizza on the West Coast. My family and I have been going to this Bonellos for many years and have always loved the consistency of great ingredients over the years. The pizza is always fresh and the service is always great. They make the orders with great quality and it shows every time I order one even to this day after going for over 20 years. Even though we have moved over the years away from San Pedro, we still find ourselves returning just for the pizza. No matter how far we have moved we have always made the trip back to this place because of how great it is. ”
“ Best pizza place ever. I grew up on their pizza.. Very good deal if you want to go get a quick slice with a salad and a drink. Service is always top tier and I will be back soon. ”
“ This place is fire , one of my favorite New York pizzas. I love to go and pick up a large pepperoni and go enjoy it at the friendship bell overlooking the ocean it's a whole vibe. Service is great always. Highly recommended when hitting San Pedro. ”
“ Great NY Style Pizza. Salad was good too. Better food than you would expect from area. ”
“ The vary best pizza in L. A. Nice guys. Good meatball sandwiches. Great sauce. It's like NY ”
“ We Ordered takeout. Got one small pepperoni pizza and one small barbecue chicken pizza with a house salad. The pizzas were pretty good. The salad was just lettuce and cheese but honestly, I should know better than to order salad at a pizza place. I do wish the pizza was a little bit thicker and Softer, but overall a pretty good place. ”
“ Great pizza. Always delicious Had to splurge on a happy roll. Now my tummy has happy rolls. The guys are very friendly and accommodating. ”
“ Honestly they deserve 5 stars! Greeted upon arrival, so much to choose from on the menu. So many options from pizza pasta and sandwiches oh and salad! So many topping options and Can I just say it's nice to be able to get a slice of pizza sometimes when you don't want a whole one. I will say it is a small space but there are about 5 tables. Let's get down to the order- Pepperoni Happy Roll Torpedo Pepperoni slice Cute little spot and very clean, you can tell they take pride in their restaurant. Be advised it is CASH ONLY, but don't let that stop you from trying the amazing food and come prepared. Parking behind building. I was overall so satisfied with the taste and quality of each piece, even the salad was so fresh and the cheese was so delicious and can taste it was some good premium cheese from the size of the pieces. The happy roll truly makes you the happiest it's just that good and the dough is perfection. It is huge and can def be shared if your appetite isn't so big. Good classic pepperoni pizza. The torpedo was just so good with all the flavors combined perfectly I can't even describe it just order it! Order it all like me to try a little of everything, you truly won't be disappointed. Might have to trek out again pretty soon, I have added it to my fave list! Can I also add the two guys there were just overall friendly and attentive. Great spot! ”
“ Very very tasty pizza, this location is small clean and they provide excellent customer service. All though it's small there is room to sit and eat comfortably. This is a cash only place. The staff treats everyone with respect and they go above and beyond to make you feel welcomed. Will definitely return to try their thick crust Sicilian pan pizza. ”
